Monday, June 10, 2013

Tax rate on interest can’t exceed 12.5% under India-UAE DTAA; surcharge and cess can’t be levied in addition

Tax payable at 12.5 per cent on interest income under Article 11(2) of the DTAA between India and UAE is inclusive of surcharge and education cess

In the instant case, the moot issue that arose for consideration of the Tribunal was as under:

Whether the assessee was liable to pay education cess and surcharge in addition to the tax @ 12.5% payable on interest income under the provisions of India-UAE DTAA?

The Tribunal held as under:

1) There are specific Articles in DTAA dealing with taxation of income under different heads and interest income is governed by Article 11;

2) According to the Article 11(2) of India-UAE DTAA, interest income may be taxed in contracting State in which it arises, according to law of that State. If the recipient is beneficial owner of interest, tax so charged shall not exceed 5 per cent of gross interest, if the interest is received from bank and in other cases at 12.5 per cent of gross amount of interest;

3) In the instant case, the tax rate applicable was 12.5 per cent. Income-tax has been defined in Article 2(2)(b) as per which income-tax includes surcharge. Therefore, tax referred to in Article 11(2) at the rate of 12.5 per cent also includes surcharge. Further, nature of education cess and surcharge being same, education cess and surcharge can’t be levied separately as it is included in tax rate of 12.5 per cent.

4)
Thus, in view of the above, it was held that tax payable at the rate 12.5 per cent under Article 11(2) of DTAA is inclusive of surcharge and education cess. Therefore, the claim of the assessee was to be allowed - Sunil V. Motiani v. ITO (International taxation ) [2013] 33 taxmann.com 252 (Mumbai - Trib.)

Friday, June 7, 2013

Sec. 54 only requires investment of cap gains, which can be in several independent residential units, HC rules

Exemption under section 54 cannot be denied, where residential house property purchased by an assessee consists of several independent units

In the instant case, the assessee had claimed deduction under section 54 in respect of two independent flats purchased by him with sale proceeds of an ancestral house property. During assessment, the AO held that deduction was to be restricted to only one flat since the two residential units purchased by the assessee were separated by a strong wall and, moreover, they were purchased from two different vendors and under separate sale deeds. On appeal, the CIT(A) sets aside the order of AO and the Tribunal confirmed the order of CIT(A). Aggrieved by the order revenue has filed the instant appeal.

The High Court held in favour of assessee as under:

1)
The expression ‘a residential house’ used in section 54(1) has to be understood in a sense that the building should be of residential nature and ‘a’ should not be understood to indicate a singular number;

2) Where assessee had purchased two residential flats, he was entitled to exemption under section 54 in respect of both the flats, more so, when the flats were situated side by side and the builder had effected modification of the flats to make them as one unit, despite the fact that the flats were purchased by separate sale deeds;

3) The two flats purchased by the assessee were adjacent to one another and had a common meeting point. Exemption under section 54 only requires that the property should be of residential nature. The fact that residential house consists of several independent units can’t be an impediment to grant relief under section 54, even if such independent units are on different floors;

4) The decision in ITO v. Shushila M. Jhaveri [2007] 107 ITD 327 (Mum) (SB) holding that only one residential house had to be given the relief under section 54 didn’t appear to be correct and was to be disapproved. Hence, sec. 54F exemption was to be granted to assessee in respect of two independent flats purchased by him – CIT v. Syed Ali Adil [2013] 33 taxmann.com 212 (Andhra Pradesh)

Thursday, June 6, 2013

Indian subsidiary providing back office support to its overseas parent co. to be treated as fixed place PE; Tribunal provides a method to allocate profits to PE

In the instant case, the assessee, i.e., 'CCMG', a US based company, providing IT enabled customer management services, had a subsidiary in india in name of CIS which was providing IT enabled call centre or back office support service to assessee to service its Indian customers. Issues that arose before the Tribunal were as under:

a) Whether assessee had a Fixed Place PE?

b) Determination of profits attributable to the alleged PE in India.

The Tribunal held as under:

On the issue of PE

1) The employees of the assessee frequently visited the premises of CIS to provide supervision, direction and control over the operations of CIS and such employees had a fixed place of business at their disposal;

2) CIS was practically the projection of assessee's business in India and carried out its business under the control and guidance of the assessee, without assuming any significant risk in relation to such functions;

3) Thus, the finding of the CIT(A) that assessee has a fixed place PE in India under Article 5(1) of the India-USA DTAA was upheld. There was no infirmity in the order of the CIT(A) that CIS did not constitute a dependent agent PE of the assessee in India as the conditions provided in paragraph 4 of Article 5 of the India-USA DTAA were not satisfied.

On the issue of profits attributable to PE

4) An overall attribution of profits to the permanent establishment is a transfer pricing issue and no further profits can be attributed to a PE once an arm's length price has been determined for the Indian associated enterprise, which subsumes the functions, assets and risk profile of the alleged PE;

5) The correct approach to arrive at the profits attributable to the PE should be as under:

Step 1: Compute global operating income percentage of the customer care business as per annual report/10K of the company.

Step 2: This percentage should be applied to the end-customer revenue with regard to contracts/projects where services were procured from CIS. The amount arrived at would be the operating income from Indian operations.

Step 3: The operating income from India operations is to be reduced by the profit before tax of CIS. This residual is now attributable between US and India.

Step 4:
The profit attributable to the PE should be estimated on residual profits as determined under Step 3 above - Convergys Customer Management Group Inc. v. ADIT (International taxation) [2013] 34 taxmann.com 24 (Delhi - Trib.)

Wednesday, June 5, 2013

‘Limitation on benefit’ clause denies treaty benefit for non-remittance of interest to Singapore

Interest on tax refund received by Singaporean resident won’t be taxed at concessional rate of 15% under Article 11 of India-Singapore DTAA, as mere proving that it has not been deposited in bank account in India wouldn’t be sufficient to prove its receipt in or remittance to Singapore to satisfy limitation of benefit clause.

In the instant case, the assessee, a resident of Singapore, had received interest on Income Tax refund. Assessee contended that it was taxable at concessional rate of 15% as per Article 11(2) of India-Singapore DTAA. However, Revenue taxed it at 20% as per section 115A by applying Article 24 (limitation on benefit) of India-Singapore DTAA. The CIT(A) upheld order of AO. Thus, the instant appeal was filed by assessee against CIT(A)’s decision.

The Tribunal held as under:

1) Article 24 of the India-Singapore DTAA limits the relief granted by other relevant Articles, including article 11 of the DTAA, subject to the fulfillment of the conditions enshrined therein;

2) Article 24 of the DTAA provides that the receipt or remittance of income in Singapore is sine qua non for claiming the benefit of lower rate of tax on the interest income from India. Thus, if the income hadn’t been remitted to or received in Singapore, then the benefit of Article-11 providing for a reduced rate of tax of 15% couldn’t be extended to the assessee. In that situation, the income would be taxed as per the Act, as had been done by the IT authorities;

3) The acceptance of Ld AR claim, that assessee had no bank account in India and, hence, the only possibility of receipt, was of receiving the amount in Singapore, would lead to making the Article 24 redundant and putting an unending burden on the Revenue to prove the negative, the positive of which is otherwise required to be established by the assessee;

4) The assessee had its presence in several countries and he could, instead of depositing the refund voucher in some bank account in Singapore, also deposit it in its bank account maintained in some other country, in which case again the requirement of Article 24 would be wanting;

5) The burden was on the assessee to prove that the amount of income was remitted to or received in Singapore. This burden could be discharged by showing a credit in the bank account maintained by the assessee in Singapore;

6) A submission not backed by any supporting evidence to prove the fulfillment of the requisite condition, couldn’t be a good reason for drawing an inference in favour of the assessee. The authorities below were justified in refusing the benefit of Article-11 of the DTAA to the assessee by taxing the interest on income-tax refund @ 20% as per section 115A of the Act - Abacus International (P.) Ltd. v. Dy. DIT( International taxation) [2013] 34 taxmann.com 21 (Mumbai - Trib.)

Saturday, June 1, 2013

No concealment penalty if exp. claimed in current year and withholding taxes deposited in subsequent year

Provision of sec. 40(a)(i) would be deemed to have been substantially complied with if taxes withheld from payment made to non-resident were deposited subsequent to the previous year in which expenditure was claimed by assessee. Hence, concealment penalty would not be leviable.

In the instant case, assessee had paid fee for technical service (‘FTS’) to non-resident and TDS thereon was deducted and deposited after the end of previous year, but before the due date of filing of income-Tax Return. However, disallowance not made by assessee of the FTS amount in return though non-deduction of TDS was reported by tax auditor in Form 3CD accompanying the return. AO imposed penalty under section 271(1)(c) in respect of FTS ‘falsely claimed. Penalty was upheld by the CIT(A). Hence the instant appeal filed by assessee against CIT(A)’s decision.

The Tribunal held as under:

1) The relevant provisions of section 40(a)(i) provides for the disallowance of specific sums payable to non-residents, where tax deducible at source, has not been deducted and deposited to the credit of the Central Government within the time prescribed under section 200(1);

2) This section is not absolute in its terms, and provides for the allowance thereof in the year of payment, i.e., where the tax stands deducted and paid after expiry of the time prescribed under section 200(1). There is, as such, no reference or correlation with the due date of the filing of the return by the assessee-deductor under section 139(1);

3) The deposit of TDS subsequently would operate as a mitigating factor. The provision itself providing for the contingency and consequence of delayed payment, deferring the claim to the year of actual payment;

4) The assessee would be entitled to claim the deduction for the immediately succeeding year, and which it has ostensibly not. In terms of the provision itself, therefore, it has become clear that it has been substantially complied with as the payment of TDS was made, though subsequently.

5) It would decidedly be a different matter if the provision made no such exception, as in that case there would be no question of the principal condition of the payment having been met and, thus, of the assessee being substantially compliant. This, therefore, served as a valid explanation under Explanation (1B) to section 271(1)(c) Thus, assessee's appeal was allowed and penalty was deleted. - Dynatron (P.) Ltd. v. Dy. CIT [2013] 33 taxmann.com 603 (Mumbai - Trib.)

Wednesday, May 29, 2013

Section 13 can’t be invoked to deny exemption if siphoning off of funds by trustee can’t be proved

In absence of material on record showing that difference in cost of construction of building disclosed by assessee-society and estimation made by DVO resulted in siphoning off of money by managing trustee, AO was not justified in denying exemption of income to assessee by invoking provisions of section 13(1)(c)

In the instant case, the assessee-society was running an educational institution. During the assessment proceedings, the AO took a view that there was huge difference in the amount claimed to have been spent by the assessee on construction of building and estimation made by the DVO and it could be concluded that the money was being siphoned out of the society to benefit the managing trustee. The AO held that there was clear violation of section 13(1)(c)(ii) and assessee was not entitled to exemption under sections 11 and 12. The CIT (A) confirmed the order of AO. Aggrieved assessee filed instant appeal.

The Tribunal held in favour of assessee as under:

1) If the person in the prohibited category renders services and in lieu thereof a benefit is provided then the case doesn’t fall in clause (ii) of section 13(1)(c);

2) A benefit would be said to have been given to the persons of prohibited category, if they in return do nothing but only enjoy the fruits of the trust/society and take away the funds/income of the society for their personal benefit or for discharging personal obligations. There was no such situation in the case under consideration;

3) Section 13 carves out an exception to the general exemption granted under sections 11 and 12. The onus lies on the revenue to bring on record cogent material/evidence to establish that the trust/charitable institution is hit by provisions of Section 13;

4) The AO had made out the case on presumption, as he had neither brought on record any evidence nor was able to point out modus operandi, and how was the managing trustee directly or indirectly benefited out of the construction cost of building of the society;

5) Thus, it was held that the AO had erroneously invoked section 13 and withdrawn benefit of section 11, read with section 12. Consequently, the appeal filed by the assessee was allowed - Amol Chand Varshney Sewa Sansthan v. ACIT [2013] 33 taxmann.com 366 (Agra - Trib.)

Expenditure disallowed for default in withholding tax would qualify for sec. 80-IB deductions

Disallowance for non-deduction of TDS liability would increase profit of assessee from business of developing housing projects and ultimate profit would qualify for deduction under section 80-IB

In the instant case, interalia, the issue that arose before the Gujarat HC was as under:

Whether disallowance under section 40(a)(ia) would  qualify for deduction under section 80IB(10) of the Act?

The High Court held as under:

Even if a expenditure incurred by the assessee for the purpose of developing housing project was not allowable by virtue of section 40(a)(ia) of the Act, since the assessee had not deducted the tax at source as required under law, it couldn’t be denied that such disallowance would ultimately go to increase the assessee's profit from the business of developing housing project. So, whatever be the ultimate profit of assessee even after making disallowance under section 40(a)(ia) of the Act, would qualify for deduction as provided for under the law. As no question of law arose, tax appeal was dismissed – ITO v. Keval Construction [2013] 33 taxmann.com 277 (Gujarat)

Method of discounted cash flow can be used for share valuation if other methods of sec. 92C are not applicable

Where assessee-company sold its stake in an Indian company to its foreign associate company, discounted cash flow method could be used for valuation of shares sold, due to non-applicability of other methods prescribed under section 92C(1)

In the instant case, the assessee-company owning 84.97% of shareholding of AITPCL India, entered into a contract with its AE for sale of its stake in AITPCL. The TPO valued the shares using discounted cash flow method and made Transfer Pricing adjustment. The objections filed by the assessee were rejected by the Dispute Resolution Panel. Aggrieved assessee filed instant appeal.

The Tribunal held as under:

1) As per Section 92C, ALP in relation to an international transaction has to be determined by one of the six methods mentioned therein;

2) Re-sale price Method couldn’t be applied in the instant case because the shares sold by the assessee were, in turn, not sold to anybody else. Cost Plus Method couldn’t be applied since assessee had made no value addition to any item. Original cost per share was only its face value, and the cost incurred which resulted in increase of its intrinsic value couldn’t be correctly ascertained. Neither Profit Split Method nor TNM Method could be used. Further, similar companies doing similar share transactions were hard to find;

3) Purpose of transfer pricing rules is to verify whether the prices at which an international transactions have been carried out is comparable with the market value of the underlying asset or commodity or service. This might require some subtle adjustments in the methodology prescribed for evaluation of an international transaction;

4) A water-tight attitude of interpretation of the prescribed methods will defeat the very purpose of enactment of transfer pricing rules and regulations and also detrimentally affect the effective and fair administration of an international tax regime;

5) Interpretation of the word 'shall' need not always be mandatory and could also be read as 'may', is a rule laid down by the Gujarat High Court in the case of CIT v.Gujarat Oil & Allied Industries [1993] 201 ITR 325;

6) Hence, while finding the most appropriate method, it is not that modern valuation methods fitting the type of underlying service or commodities have to be ignored. Fixing enterprise value based on discounted value of future profits or cash flow is a method used worldwide.

Endeavour was only at arriving at a value which would give a comparable uncontrolled price for the shares sold. If viewed from this angle, it couldn’t be said that the discounted cash flow method adopted by the TPO was not in accordance with section 92C(1) - Ascendas (India) (P. )Ltd. v. Dy.CIT [2013] 33 taxmann.com 295 (Chennai - Trib.)

Saturday, May 25, 2013

Services availed for market research and customer’s credit rating are eligible for input credit

Management consultancy service availed by assessee relating to conduct of 'market research' and customers 'credit rating' in international market to improve its market condition abroad is eligible for input service credit

In the instant case, the assessee availed of management consultancy service relating to conduct of market research and customers credit rating in international market to improve its market condition abroad. The Department denied credit on ground that that there was no nexus of these services with manufacture.

The Tribunal held as under:

1. The definition of input services in the inclusive portion clearly includes market research services on which credit is available;

2. Credit rating of customers also relatables to sales promotion and business of manufacture. In any case, as the activity was specifically included in the definition of input services, credit thereof couldn’t be denied -  Gujarat Reclaim & Rubber Products Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise [2013] 33 taxmann.com 276 (Ahmedabad - CESTAT)

Friday, May 24, 2013

Sec. 54F benefit available on sum invested in construction of house nonetheless parts of investment may be from different sources and not from cap gains

Where capital gain is assessed on notional basis under section 50C, whatever amount is invested in new residential house within prescribed period under section 54F would get benefit of deduction nonetheless parts of the investments may be from different sources and not from capital gains

In the instant case, the assessee had sold a house property for Rs. 20 lakhs having registration value of Rs 36 lakhs as fixed by the State authorities under the Stamp Act and had sought exemption under section 54F as he had re-invested Rs. 24 lakh for construction of residential house. The AO had deducted the cost price of land paid by the assessee at Rs. 1.93 lakhs and Rs. 20 lakhs towards investment in construction of residential house from the value of Rs 36 lakhs of the property under section 50C, and determined the long-term capital gain of Rs. 14.06 lakhs.The Tribunal upheld the order of the AO. Aggrieved by the order of Tribunal, assessee filed the instant appeal.

The HC held in favour of assessee as under:

1) The assessee had stated that he has invested Rs. 20 lakhs out of the sale consideration and had made further investment of Rs. 4 lakhs of agricultural income towards construction of the house. The total amount shown to have been invested for construction of house was Rs. 24 lakhs. The benefit of exemption of Rs. 4 lakhs was disallowed, which didn’t appear to be sound and proper;

2) As the ultimate object and purpose of section 50C is to see that the undisclosed income of capital gains received by the assessees should be taxed and the law should not encourage and permit the assessee to peg down the market value at his whims and fancy to avoid tax. In other words, the ultimate object is to curb the growth of black money;

3) When the capital gain is assessed on a notional basis, whatever amount is invested in new residential house within the prescribed period under section 54F, the assessee should get the benefit of deduction, irrespective of the fact that the funds from other sources are utilized for new residential house;

4) In that context, whatever amount was actually invested by the assessee for construction of house should be deducted, irrespective of the fact that parts of the investments were from different sources and not from the capital gains. Thus, full reinvestment made by assessee (i.e., 24 lakhs) in construction of residential house was to be allowed under section 54F - Gouli Mahadevappa v. ITO [2013] 33 taxmann.com 47 (Karnataka)